Punky's friendship with Cherie is put to the test when Cherie falls for Donald Sotta, a new boy in the neighborhood, and Cherie begins to spend more time with Donald than she does with Punky, making a jealous Punky think Cherie likes Donald more than she likes Punky, until Cherie proves Punky wrong by telling Punky that Cherie loves Punky as her best friend, and Cherie doesn't like Donald so much anymore because all Donald cares about is baseball, basketball, and wrestling.
Season 0
Season 1
Season 2
Season 3
Season 4
Reading, Writing, and Rock & Roll Punky's Big Story Tons of Fun Divorce Anderson Style Beer & Buffalos Don't Mix Hands Across the Halls Open Door, Broken Heart (1) Open Door, Broken Heart (2) Best Friends It's a Dog's Life The Metamorphosis Fighting City Hall The Matchmaker My Fair Punky The Anniversary Tangled Web Punky's Porker This Spud's for You So Long, Studio Help Wanted Remember When Unhooking Henry
Reading, Writing, and Rock & Roll Punky's Big Story Tons of Fun Divorce Anderson Style Beer & Buffalos Don't Mix Hands Across the Halls Open Door, Broken Heart (1) Open Door, Broken Heart (2) Best Friends It's a Dog's Life The Metamorphosis Fighting City Hall The Matchmaker My Fair Punky The Anniversary Tangled Web Punky's Porker This Spud's for You So Long, Studio Help Wanted Remember When Unhooking Henry