Season 1
Pete Holmes Jacqueline Novak Christian Finnegan Michael Phelps Breakfast in Five Minutes Craig Baldo Donald Glover Jake and Amir Stuckey and Murray Roger Hailes One DC Pierson Justin Kredible Eliza Skinner Jake and Amir 2 Jamie Lee Matt McCarthy Simon Rich Jake and Amir 3 Jared Logan Hardly Working Shane Mauss Believe! Baron Vaughn Thomas Middleditch Jeff Rubin God’s Pottery Jake and Amir 4 Streeter Seidell Adam Newman Jon Dore High Times vs. Engineering Students Bo Burnham Jake and Amir 5 Pete Holmes Pangea 3000 Jake and Amir 6 Kumail Nanjiani Freestyle Love Supreme Ryan Reiss Jake and Amir 7 Hannibal Buress Dan Levy Jon Gabrus Josh Ruben Jake and Amir 8 Chris Gethard Seth Herzog Pete and Pete Trivia